You saved the money. You built the emergency fund. You did every single thing you were told to do.
So why does spending it feel like losing something?
Today I’m welcoming back Jean Chatzky, who spent 25 years as the Today show’s financial editor, founded HerMoney, and has a new book out called The Forever Paycheck. Honestly, she’s one of the people who shaped how I think about money in the first place. We’re getting into money hoarding: why disciplined savers have such a hard time enjoying what they built, and where that “don’t touch it or you won’t be safe” instinct comes from. Jean breaks down how to turn part of your savings into a paycheck so spending feels normal again. And we talk about the harder question underneath all of it, which is figuring out what you actually want your money to pay for.
Key takeaways:
Hoarding your savings is about loss, not math
When you’ve spent decades watching a balance grow, seeing it go down feels like losing something you built with your own sweat. Jean points out that researchers see the same behavior with the good bottle of wine, the spa gift card, the really nice box of chocolates. We’re more afraid of using them too soon than we are of never using them at all. Your retirement account works the same way, and so does your emergency fund. If your car breaks and you put the repair on a credit card to “protect” your savings, that’s the hoarding instinct talking. The car is the emergency. That’s what the money is for.
Saving turns into hoarding when your money can’t do its job
Jean’s line between the two is simple. If you have the money and holding onto it is stopping you from doing the things you saved it for (the trips, the restaurants, helping your kids, whatever’s on your list), it’s become a problem. She’s clear this applies to people who actually have the money. It’s not a push to spend what you don’t have.
People spend a paycheck more freely than a pile
Research Jean shares compared people with equal wealth, some holding it as a lump sum in a 401(k) and some receiving it as a pension. The pension group spent about twice as much, because they knew another check was coming. That’s the whole idea behind the forever paycheck: turn part of your savings into income so spending feels like spending your salary, not draining your account.
You can build a paycheck or buy one
Buying one means an annuity: you hand an insurance company a chunk of money and they pay you a set amount for the rest of your life. Building one means income-producing investments, like a ladder of bonds or CDs (staggered so they pay out on a schedule), TIPS (government bonds that adjust for inflation), dividend-paying stocks, or funds designed to produce income. Annuities give you guarantees that investments can’t. Investments give you upside annuities can’t. If you hate risk, lean insurance. If you’d kick yourself for missing a market boom, lean investments.
The 4% rule has some cracks
The classic approach is to withdraw 4% of your retirement savings in year one, adjust for inflation every year after, and expect it to last 30 years. Jean explains why that rule is under fire: we’re living longer, markets are more volatile, and a bad market in the decade around your retirement date can wreck the math. Her alternative is to convert about a third of your money into a paycheck, max out Social Security as the base, and invest the rest. Because your essentials are covered, you can actually afford to invest that remaining money more aggressively.
You can’t spend with confidence if you don’t know what you want
This is the part I see over and over. Women are taught not to want things, or that wanting is unbecoming, so of course we don’t know what to save for or spend on. Jean says she didn’t really know what she wanted until close to 40. Her test: if you keep coming back to something again and again, take it seriously and make it a goal. If it just popped up on your Instagram, maybe not. And check whether it’s actually yours or something you were told to want.
You can practice this now
You don’t have to wait until 65. Jean suggests looking at the income estimate on your retirement statement (many now show what your balance would pay out monthly) instead of just the big total.
Notable quotes
“Our deep-seated fear is that we’ll regret using them too soon more than we will regret never using them.”
“This is not your fault. The system was built to make you feel, if not bad about spending this money, then at least questionable about spending this money.”
“This is your life. This is your money. These are your choices. You have to justify them to you. That is the only person you have to justify them to.”
Episode at-a-glance
00:00 Intro
01:50 Why disciplined savers can’t spend
02:53 The fear of loss (and the good wine problem)
04:52 “That’s not a real emergency”
06:07 The forever paycheck idea
07:07 Where saving turns into hoarding
09:06 Build a paycheck or buy one
11:57 The 4% rule and why it’s under fire
12:53 Turning about a third of your money into income
14:29 Have money experts made spending too scary?
15:22 The backwards budget
17:15 Why women don’t know what they want
18:39 How Jean figured out what she wanted
20:24 Wanting what you were told to want
22:40 You don’t have to justify your money
23:45 Saving it for the kids? Not as often as you’d think
24:54 Holding money as a form of control
25:41 How to set up your forever paycheck
27:30 Practicing the saver-to-spender shift now
28:55 We’re all spenders eventually
31:09 Why women fear running out of money
32:31 Getting ready to spend down
34:06 Jean’s advice for the woman with the pit in her stomach
35:01 The Forever Paycheck
Thanks to Rocket Money for sponsoring this episode!
Thanks to BetterHelp for sponsoring this episode!
Jean’s Links:
Website: https://hermoney.com/
Get Jean’s book, The Forever Paycheck: https://jeanchatzky.com/books/
Also Mentioned in this Episode:
What to Do If You’re 35+ and Feel Financially Behind with Jean Chatzky
Check out Tori on the HerMoney podcast
Ready to feel more confident with money and stop figuring it all out alone? The $100K Club is for you. Learn more at: https://herfirst100k.com/ffpod.
RESOURCES:
Looking for accountability and deeper financial education? Join the $100K Club
Our HYSA Partner Recommendation (terms apply)
Behind the Scenes and Extended Clips on Youtube
Leave Financial Feminist a Voicemail
Financial Feminist on Instagram
Take our FREE Money Personality Quiz
Meet Jean
Jean Chatzky is the founder and CEO of HerMoney and the host of “HerMoney With Jean Chatzky.” Jean is a columnist for AARP, a coach on the PBS TV show Opportunity Knocks and a research fellow with the LIMRA Retirement Income Institute. Previously, she spent 25 years as the Financial Editor on NBC’s Today Show and was a contributor to Oprah. Jean is an award-winning journalist and broadcaster, a New York Times and Wall Street Journal best-selling author, and a fierce advocate for financial literacy. Her next book, The Forever Paycheck: The New Retirement Strategy to Spend More, Worry Less and Never Run Out Of Money will be published by Avery in September. Find her at HerMoney.com or @JeanChatzky everywhere.
Transcript:
Tori Dunlap:
You can do everything you’re told to do with your money. Save, invest, build the emergency fund, but yet still feel a pit in your stomach every time that you have to spend your savings. So what does that actually mean and what can we actually do about it? If you’ve been around this community for a while, you know today’s guest, Jean Chatzky. She spent 25 years as the Today show’s financial editor and she’s the founder of HerMoney. And honestly, she’s one of the people who shaped how a lot of us think about money in the first place, including myself. We’re getting into today, the psychology of money hoarding, and specifically, feeling guilty about spending your money, especially spending your own retirement. She talks today about how disciplined savers have such a hard time actually enjoying what they built and where that don’t touch it or you won’t be safe instinct comes from.
And we talk about how to build the permission to spend instead of waiting 30 years and still not feeling ready because you don’t just want a big number in an account, you want to be able to say, “Yes.” Yes to the trip you can actually afford, yes to quitting the toxic job because you built a safety net, and yes to living out the retirement of your dreams instead of just watching your money sit there. And we built something for exactly that. The $100K Club gives you a system for actually spending and enjoying your money on purpose, guilt-free, and right now, it’s under $100. You can get it at herfirst100k.com/ffpod. All right, let’s get into it. But first, a word from our sponsors.
Jean, I’m so excited to have you back on the show. What makes it so hard for disciplined savers to actually spend the money they’ve worked so hard to build?
Jean Chatzky:
It is a big mind game, Tori, and thank you for having me back. After what’s really been four decades of saving, paying yourself first, grabbing all the matching dollars, maxing out your retirement, you’ve watched this balance in your 401k or whatever kind of account you have, grow and grow and grow. It’s become incredibly precious. And it turns out that watching it go in the other direction, even though this is exactly what this money was planned for, is tremendously uncomfortable. And so, we’re seeing a generation of people not spending in retirement.
Tori Dunlap:
Where does this hoarding instinct come from? What are we trying to either prevent or what are we trying to guarantee when we don’t spend our own money, even the money that we have saved to spend?
Jean Chatzky:
We’re trying to prevent the feeling of loss. When we spend it, it feels like losing it because that big number that we have emotionally grabbed onto is starting to decrease even if just by a little bit. And for that reason, we are so reluctant to spend it. There are a lot of fears out there about market volatility, about inflation, about interest rates, but it’s really this idea that this thing that you built with sweat equity and hard work and all those years of slog could start to vanish. And it’s an experience that researchers have studied when it comes to other things that we think of as precious. So they’ve looked at things like bottles of wine that are particularly good or that we received as gifts, gift cards to spas and great restaurants, really, really nice boxes of chocolates. And what they discovered is that this stuff gets hoarded too.
These things are all considered sort of precious cargo and our deep-seated fear is that we’ll regret using them too soon more than we will regret never using them. 90% of us have these bucket lists. We have these dreams that we have been working for and not to do them because we’ve got some sort of psychological roadblock in the way, is not okay.
Tori Dunlap:
Yeah, that concept of the good china, the good china or the good bottle of wine, it’s so common and it’s such an interesting connection to what you’re talking about here of, oh, I got to save it for when it’s actually an event, in the same way we’ve got to save it for when it’s actually an emergency. Do we see this sort of hoarding tendency for things beyond retirement for things like our emergency fund or anything else we’re also saving for?
Jean Chatzky:
We absolutely see it for our emergency fund. I’ve heard so many times, and I’m sure you’ve heard people say, “Oh, well, that’s not a real emergency. Oh, something happened to my car. That’s not a real emergency. This was just a small incident. I’ll pull that money from somewhere else. I’ll put that money on a credit card.”
No, that’s an emergency. That’s what you have this money for. But we bucket the money in such strange ways in our minds that we have to figure out some sort of a workaround. We’ve got all these principles now that have helped us save for retirement. We’ve got automatic enrollment into 401k plans and automatic escalation of contributions and defaults into target date funds to help keep our money invested appropriately.
All of that stuff has helped us get out of our ways, avoid these harmful human tendencies that would make us not spend or not save. We don’t have that for spending, but we need to figure out a way to essentially, systematize the spending in the same way that we’ve systematized the savings so that we can enjoy our retirement.
And what I’m putting out in this book, what I’m putting forward, this idea of a forever paycheck works because we spend income differently than we spend assets, big chunks of money. A lot of research has looked at the different behaviors, but I actually saw it in my own life with my mom who, for 20 years after my dad died, spent social security, spent the interest that she got on the retirement accounts, spent the small pension that my father left, but would not spend that principle despite the fact that she had three grown kids telling her, “We don’t need your money. This is your money. Spend your money. We don’t want your money.” She couldn’t do it. She couldn’t bring herself to see that number that she had anchored to, go down.
Tori Dunlap:
What is the line between saving and hoarding and how do you know when you’ve crossed it?
Jean Chatzky:
The line has to do with not allowing your money to do the job that you saved it for. So, we all have visions of retirement or at least visions of what the next couple of decades of our lives are going to look like. And if we’ve been detailed about it, we’ve got vacations that we want to take. We’ve got restaurants that we want to visit. We’ve got ways that we perhaps want to help our kids. We’ve got a whole laundry list of things that we want to accomplish. If holding onto your money is preventing you from checking those items off your list, when you have the money, right? I’m not talking about people who don’t have the money, but when you have the money, then it has become a problem.
But you can get around the problem by taking a chunk of the assets and actually converting it to a stream of income. Because when researchers looked at people with equal amounts of wealth, some structured as a big chunk of assets, money in a 401 some structured as a pension, they were perhaps teachers or military who had that money coming in the form of a paycheck for the rest of their lives, but level playing field, the people with the paychecks spent twice as much because they just knew that there was another paycheck where that one came from.
Tori Dunlap:
I think it’s also less daunting if you’ve spent your entire life earning to think about, “Oh yeah, I’m spending this normal paycheck,” versus, “Here is my monopoly pile of money and I’m just going to watch that go down.” It’s so psychological, the difference, which is so interesting. So how do we set up an income for ourselves in a world where pensions aren’t really a thing anymore?
Jean Chatzky:
Right. That’s the big problem. Our parents, grandparents, certainly, they had these pensions, but we’ve grown up with this 401 system that came around in the ’80s and stuck because corporations didn’t want to be responsible for our retirements anymore. Two ways to build a paycheck. You can build one or you can buy one. You buy one with insurance. In other words, with annuities. You take a chunk of money, you sign a contract with an insurance company, you get a paycheck for the rest of your life. There are a lot of different kinds of annuities. They have their pros and cons. We can talk through that if you want to.
The other way to do it is with income producing investments, ladders of bonds or CDs or tips that have inflation protection, dividend paying stocks. There are certain mutual funds and index funds these days that are designed to be income producing. The difference between the two is that insurance annuities can provide guarantees that investments can’t. Investments can provide upside that insurance can’t. And so, if you are the kind of person who doesn’t like risk, if you’re the kind of person who says, “I want this paycheck to come, I want to know that this amount of money is locked in, I don’t want to have to think about it anymore,” then you’ve got to go the insurance route. If you’re the kind of person that has a little more FOMO, and if the market goes crazy in a good way, you are going to be kicking yourself because you’re missing out on that upside, then you got to go with the investments.
Tori Dunlap:
One of the things I tell people in our investing programs all the time is that as you get closer to retirement, you do have to think about prepping for that retirement by moving some of your money into things that are not as volatile. I also don’t think we talk enough about though that lets say, okay, you turn 65, you have enough money to retire in an ideal scenario, you don’t pull all of your money out of the market in one fell swoop, right? If you have two million in the market, let’s say, you’re not saying, “Okay, I’m going to pull all of that out and that’s the exact money I need right now.” Talk to me about what that strategy is, of slowly withdrawing the money so the other money can keep growing for you and how that psychologically might be easier for us to understand too versus okay, big pile of money.
Jean Chatzky:
So when you are looking at spending down in retirement, the traditional way that we have done it is with what we call the 4% rule where you take 4% of your money from your retirement accounts out in year one, that’s your spending money. And then every year thereafter, you adjust that amount for inflation and the money based on that rule was supposed to last you 30 years.
That rule of thumb has been under fire over the last decade for a whole number of reasons. Number one, 30 years may not be enough, right? We are living, we’re living longer, but also, market volatility has just gotten much, much greater in recent years. And if you hit a bear market anywhere in the 10 years around your retirement before or after, the chances that that rule will serve you, go way down.
So, what I’m suggesting is that you take some money and you divert it to income, not all of your money, about a third of your money, and you either do it in the investing track or the insurance track, but then you invest the rest of your money. You can actually invest it more aggressively because you know that your forever paycheck is going to continue to come. And the size of the paycheck, the about a third, everybody should first focus on maxing out social security. Social security is the base of a forever paycheck. You want to get as much as you possibly can out of that, but then you got to look at what your life costs you and how much you need to have coming in order to cover those things that you need, but also, those things that you want enough not to be willing to compromise on them.
So for me, that first vacation of the year, my gym membership is sacrosanct. There are things that I know that I’m going to want to pay for pretty much forever, and I want my forever paycheck to cover those things. As far as the things that are more discretionary, more wishes than needs and wants, I’ll take care of that with the money that’s invested in the markets, knowing that it can be a little bit more volatile because it’s not truly going to affect the quality of my life.
Tori Dunlap:
I want to take a meta view of our work collectively, you and I, and all of the financial experts, because we spend a lot of our energy warning people about not saving enough, and I think for good reason.
Jean Chatzky:
Yes.
Tori Dunlap:
It’s never been more expensive to live. Retirement is the biggest expense of your life. And I think especially some of our colleagues who might be more shame-based are so focused on never spend money, never buy anything nice, that it is so difficult when we have reached the finish line to then feel like, “Am I safe enough to actually spend money?” So, what is the advice between saving and prioritizing that and making sure that you’ve actually got enough with then being okay saying, “Yeah, it is enough and I can spend it.”
Jean Chatzky:
Two things here. First of all, we all need savings goals. We need to look at our numbers. We need to know what our life costs all across the continuum. What does my life cost when I’m in my 30s and I want to accomplish A, B, and C? What does my life look when I’m in my 50s and my kids are in college? What is my life going to cost when I’m actually retiring and maybe my mortgage is paid off or close to paid off, or maybe it’s not, or maybe I want to buy a second home? What is your life actually going to cost you? Because if you don’t know that, then it’s impossible to answer any of those questions. I’ve always approached the what can I spend question with sort of a backwards budget. I know what my savings goals are, I know what I have to do to meet them.
And this has been true during the years when I was shoving money into 529s for my kids because I was trying to make up ground in terms of the half of college I had to pay for after my divorce, but also, my retirement goals when I wanted to pay off the mortgage. I did all that stuff first. Whatever was left was the money that I told myself was discretionary. Despite that, it’s not always easy to spend it, particularly if you were raised in a house where your parents were frugal, where they held tight onto things. And I was raised in one of those houses. And so, the mantra that I repeat to myself and I’ve gotten my husband on this bandwagon is this is why we work.
Tori Dunlap:
You and I mentioned, I was just on your show and you just brought it up again here that we have to figure out what our money is funding, what life we want our money to fund. The problem I see over and over and over again though, is women don’t know what they want. And I think this is a bigger psychological and systemic issue of we are not told to want as women. We are not brought up to actually desire anything for ourselves. We are putting everybody else’s needs and everybody else’s desires above our own. And also, it is bad or unbecoming of women to want or desire. And also, I’m just seeing this over and over again where of course, you don’t know what to save for or therefore what to spend money on because you don’t actually know what you want.
And I have admired you and continue to admire you for so long, and you are older than me, and I think there’s a lot of members of our audience that would love to hear from your perspective, how did you figure out what you wanted and how can someone listening who maybe is like, “I don’t know what I should want,” figure that out for themselves?
Jean Chatzky:
It’s such a good question. And honestly, Tori, I don’t think I knew what I wanted until I was close to 40.
Tori Dunlap:
Yeah.
Jean Chatzky:
40 was the year when I got divorced, when I got fired, when my father died. It was a shitty year all the way around. And I turned 40, which at the time was not super exciting for me.
Tori Dunlap:
Devastating, yeah, yeah.
Jean Chatzky:
But when I got divorced and I was on my own again, I had two kids, but I was on my own again for the first time, I was really surprised at how I was able to lean into and figure out what I wanted. Sometimes, I think we have to sit with these uncomfortable questions and uncomfortable situations in order to listen to our guts enough so that they tell us what we want.
When you come back to something again and again and again, chances are pretty good that that is something that you really want. When it’s something that you see in the moment and you think about it in the flash in the [inaudible 00:20:08], “Oh, it popped up on my Instagram. Instagram’s telling me I got to go to Croatia. Maybe I should go to Croatia.” I don’t really care about going to Croatia, right? Maybe one day I’ll get there. But if it’s something that you come back to again and again and again, then maybe you make it a goal. And if you’re willing to do the work to figure out how to make that goal a reality, then I think that’s something that you should take seriously.
Tori Dunlap:
I think that’s very wise. And I also think that we always have to investigate, okay, is this just what I was told to want? Is this just what I was told to crave? And I think home ownership is the perfect example of this where sometimes, for people, it’s just the thing that we were told is the marker of success. Or even having children, it’s like you were told as a woman, over and over and over again that that was your role. Maybe that is desperately what you want. Amazing. Maybe it’s not. And I think that we are so good at being disconnected from our knowing because that’s what patriarchy wants. And also because it keeps us broken, it keeps us unhappy, and it is not very fulfilling to do things that we don’t really like.
Jean Chatzky:
I think we do them all the time. I think we do them to please other people. I think we do them to please the ghosts that taught us that we were supposed to want those things to begin with. Interesting when you talk about kids. I had my first fairly young, I was close to 30, but at 28, I didn’t want a child. At 29, I didn’t quite want a child. It wasn’t until, I don’t know, something happened, something changed in me that I actually wanted one. And then I didn’t want a second until I wanted a second. It was a very strange sort of a roller coaster. And I’ve talked to a number of women who they feel that way.
I think when those impulses come along, whether it’s to start a business or whether it’s to move across the country or whatever it is, it deserves exploration to figure out why you want this. Where is this idea coming from? What is it going to do for you? What is it going to take away from you? There’s a trade-off for everything. How are you going to change your life in order to accommodate this change that you might make?
Tori Dunlap:
Yeah. And I think this relates back to everything you’re talking about, especially in this new book and your work of it does feel selfish to take your money out. I think that is kind of what we’re fighting of like, “Oh, what if I need it for something else?” And also, “Oh, this is my money, I guess, but it doesn’t feel that way,” and it’s selfish to use it in the same way that it’s selfish to want things and to do the things that might not make sense to other people, but that makes sense to us. And I think that justification is always what we’re fighting of. I have to justify my decisions. I have to justify me taking my money out of my account. And I’m like, “No, you don’t.”
Jean Chatzky:
No.
Tori Dunlap:
This is your life. This is your money. These are your choices. You have to justify them to you. That is the only person you have to justify them to.
Jean Chatzky:
There’s a segment of people who have been asking me the question, well, are people not spending because this is money that they are leaving for their kids or for their causes? Have they earmarked this money for others? In the research that I’ve done, that is not as common as you might think. We do want to help our children and we definitely want to take care of those organizations that are important to us, but it’s much more this roadblock of getting attached to having this big amount, this big mound of money and not wanting to not have it. There’s security, and you and I talked about this. There is security in having a big chunk of money. Often, it’s in the bank where it shouldn’t be, but once you see those numbers declining, it feels a little less secure and there are other ways to provide yourself with that same feeling of safety and security while also getting to enjoy the life that you have fought so long to create along the way.
Tori Dunlap:
Yeah. I think it’s also control manifesting. If we have very little control over our circumstances, over the reality of everything happening right now, I think it’s one way that we have this false sense of security and control of, again, I can see my money in my account or I know how much money I have in my investments and I can control when and how I take that money out, and so, I’m just not going to take it out ever. That’s probably a response to that control mechanism or that feeling of wanting control.
Jean Chatzky:
Yeah, because if I take it out, what happens to it? If I take it out, then I have to make additional choices.
Tori Dunlap:
So, we’re talking about the solve for that is thinking about your money as income. Walk me through how to actually set up that kind of system. What are the logistics of making this lump sum of money feel more like income?
Jean Chatzky:
Well, you’re actually going to make it income. You’re going to make some of it income, but the first step is really figuring out what’s your gap. So, what is this life of needs and most important wants going to cost? How much is social security going to cover? What’s the gap? And how much of your assets do you need to convert to income in order to essentially cover that gap? Once you know that number, then you can decide if you’re an insurance person or an investment person. If you’re an insurance person, then you go shopping for an annuity. It’s something that you are going to want to do in your 50s, your early 60s, where you take a look at the different products that are on the market and which ones seem to fit with the kind of an amount of income you want.
If you’re an investing person, you take that chunk of your investments. Typically, it’s what you had in your bond portfolio or your fixed income, and you convert it into income producing investments that will spill off a check that will land in your bank account as you need it. It’s not all that complicated. It’s really this mental leap that you have to make that having a continuing income will provide you with the ease to just go on living your life as you want to live it.
Tori Dunlap:
Can someone practice this saver to spender mindset before they even get to retirement?
Jean Chatzky:
Practicing looks like looking at your 401K statement. Today, your 401K statement and your retirement account statements give you a number of what your balance will produce in income. If you can start focusing on that number and not just the big nest egg number, that’s going to start to shift your thinking into what will this eventually buy me? And the really good news for many of your listeners is that systemically, this is, in about 10 years, going to get much, much easier. So income products are slowly making their way into retirement accounts. We’re starting to see a lot of the big 401K, 403B providers of work-based plans adding an income track.
Somewhere around age 50, you’re going to get asked, “Do you want to go on the income track? Do you want to divert a third of your money into an income producing solution?” And then again, somewhere around age 65, you’re probably going to get asked, “Do you actually want to turn this on or do you want to put it back into the big nest egg?” It’s not coming soon enough for Gen Xers. It’s not necessarily coming soon enough for the oldest millennials, but it is coming.
Tori Dunlap:
And one of the mindset shifts I talked about in my book is I always joke I could win an Olympic gold medal in saving money. And also, this binary of are you a saver or are you a spender doesn’t really exist because even the money that I have saved will be spent. And I think the goal is to figure out what is it spent on? So yes, my emergency fund will be spent on emergencies. My retirement account will be spent providing for my retirement. My home savings account was spent for me buying a house. I think that we can just switch our identity too of are you a saver? Are you a spender? We’re all spenders at the end of the day, actually. You just might not spend the money right now. You might spend it next month on a vacation. You might spend it in a couple years on a house, you might spend it in a couple decades on retiring or maybe years, depending on your age.
But I do think that that has been helpful for even me personally to give myself more permission to spend money as it’s like even the stuff I’m saving, I will spend that money.
Jean Chatzky:
I do that too. I went on a big trip for my 50th birthday. I took the entire clan to Hawaii and I wanted to take everybody in style, but I did not want to look at the credit card bills. So I saved the money before. I just 401K’d it. I made automatic transfers into a vacation account for a good year before we went on this trip. The money was there. It was very easy to spend because it was for that vacation. And that’s sort of the mind shift that people need to make. This is my retirement income. This is my retirement investments. It’s very much a binary split, but you got to get yourself thinking, this is my spending money. This is my allowance. However, you want to think about it.
Tori Dunlap:
Is there something specific about how women are taught about money that makes all of this just worse for us?
Jean Chatzky:
Many of us are taught that there is not more where that came from. The fear of running out of money in retirement is much more pervasive in women than it is in men. When you look at the statistics, men think their money will last as long as retirement lasts. Women think ours will run out five years too soon.
And when you look at how women are compensated and how much we have in our retirement accounts when we get to the end of the road, it makes perfect sense. The math has not been in our favor. As you particularly look at the fact that there is this transfer of wealth coming our way, it is going to land in the hands of women. We are going to outlive the men in our lives. We are going to be the ones that have to spend down these retirement dollars in the end or have the opportunity to spend them down in the end. We want to be able to make the most of that money. And that means getting comfortable with the idea of using it.
Tori Dunlap:
You made a point at the beginning of this conversation that I want to come back to, which is you’ve been working so hard for your own retirement, right? You’ve been putting money away and putting money away. This is your money to spend. And with that motivation of, okay, I have put all this money aside, it’s now time to spend it. Is it visualizing what that looks like? Is it again, having a really clear picture of where our money’s going? If we are at retirement age or getting closer to it, is there the mindset work that we can be doing to get comfortable starting to spend that money?
Jean Chatzky:
I think two things. Number one, absolutely visualize where it’s going to go. Write it down, where it’s going to go. Figure out how much those things are going to cost and how much you want to allocate to those things. Make a plan for how you’re going to use that money, but then build yourself a system that makes it easier to use that money. Acknowledge the fact that if it sits in a nest egg, there is going to be a roadblock. It is going to be harder for you. And so, just like you make it easier to exercise in the morning by sleeping in your running clothes as I do, set yourself up with some systems that ensure that you are going to have success with this.
Tori Dunlap:
Okay. So there’s a woman listening. She has the emergency fund, she has the retirement account, she has the discipline, but she still feels that pit in her stomach every time she spends on herself. What do you want her to understand before she waits another 10 years to actually enjoy what she saved?
Jean Chatzky:
This is not your fault. The system was built to make you feel, if not bad about spending this money, then at least questionable about spending this money. So, do two things. Get yourself a paycheck, whether you buy it or you build it, and then make sure that you know exactly what you want to spend this money on and when you want to do it. Sometimes, when we have a timeframe, we’re a lot more successful in accomplishing our goals than if it’s just someday.
Tori Dunlap:
I think that’s so wise. I’m so excited for this next book. Tell me everything about it.
Jean Chatzky:
Thank you.
Tori Dunlap:
Tell me where we can read it.
Jean Chatzky:
The book is The Forever Paycheck. You can get it anywhere books are sold. And if you’re looking for more information about it, you can just go to jeanchatzky.com. There’re all the links to all the places right there.
Tori Dunlap:
Amazing. Thank you so much for being here again.
Jean Chatzky:
Thanks for having me.
Tori Dunlap:
Thank you for listening to Financial Feminists, produced by Her First $100K. If you love the show and want to keep supporting feminist media, please subscribe or follow us on your preferred podcasting platform or on YouTube. Your support helps us continue to bring this content to you for free. If you’re looking for resources, tools, and education, including all of the resources mentioned in this episode, head to http://herfirst100k.com/ffpod.
Financial Feminist is hosted by me, Tori Dunlap. Produced by Ellice Ellis and Tamisha Grant. Audio and video engineering by Jonathan Kirk. Marketing and Operations by Karina Patel and Amanda Leffew. Special thanks to our team at Her First $100K, Masha Bakhmetyeva, Rae Wong, Daryl Ann Ingman, Meghan Walker, Marciella Baietto, Demi Ganim, Taylor Toll, Zoe Rezek and Stormy McBride. Promotional graphics by Mary Stratton, photography by Sarah Wolfe, and theme music by Jonah Cohen Sound. A huge thanks to the entire Her First 100K community for supporting our show.

Tori Dunlap
Tori Dunlap is an internationally-recognized money and career expert. After saving $100,000 at age 25, Tori quit her corporate job in marketing and founded Her First $100K to fight financial inequality by giving women actionable resources to better their money. She has helped over five million women negotiate salaries, pay off debt, build savings, and invest.
Tori’s work has been featured on Good Morning America, the New York Times, BBC, TIME, PEOPLE, CNN, New York Magazine, Forbes, CNBC, BuzzFeed, and more.
With a dedicated following of over 2.1 million on Instagram and 2.4 million on TikTok —and multiple instances of her story going viral—Tori’s unique take on financial advice has made her the go-to voice for ambitious millennial women. CNBC called Tori “the voice of financial confidence for women.”
An honors graduate of the University of Portland, Tori currently lives in Seattle, where she enjoys eating fried chicken, going to barre classes, and attempting to naturally work John Mulaney bits into conversation.